About now alarm bells should be going off in your head. Why?
George just purchased a policy designed for the renters themselves, not the property owner. Asking for a renters policy meant that George was covering (and paying for) the personal belongings of his tenants, and leaving his property totally unprotected.
As a landlord, you are responsible for the property itself. Be sure to get a policy that is designed for the owner, rather than the renter. Your policy should cover the structure itself against fire and hail, for example. And be sure to add liability to it, in case your tenant or a visitor decides to sue.